Posts

Building a New Astronomy Without a Telescope: Why Critical Interactionism Cannot Ignore EM/CA

Image
                                Building a New Astronomy Without a Telescope:   Why Critical Interactionism Cannot Ignore EM/CA Wayne Martin Mellinger, Ph.D. Michael Hviid Jacobsen’s Critical and Cultural Interactionism (2019) assembles some of the most distinguished voices in symbolic interactionism—Greg Smith, Michael Schwalbe, Adele Clarke, Sherryl Kleinman, among others—to chart a revitalized critical agenda. The collection demonstrates the enduring vitality of symbolic interactionist (SI) thought, its capacity for cultural critique, and its adaptability to new social conditions. Yet its silence on ethnomethodology and conversation analysis (EM/CA) is striking. To attempt a new critical sociology of interaction while ignoring EM/CA is like trying to build a new astronomy while refusing to look through a telescope. The tools are there, and they have opened up an entirely new field of v...

Michael Hviid Jacobsen's Introduction to Critical and Cultural Interactionism (2019)

Image
From Michael Hviid Jacobsen (Ed.) Critical and Cultural Interactionism. (2019). Routledge.   Introduction The coming of critical and cultural interactionisms Michael Hviid Jacobsen This book is an invitation to what is here termed ‘critical and cultural ­ interactionisms’. We shall in a bit more detail return to the purpose and con- tent of this notion later. The book is a creative offspring from another volume I had the privilege and pleasure of editing a few years ago titled The Interactionist Imagination (Jacobsen 2017), which explored some of the many different roots and variations of interactionist sociology. When completing that volume, I came to consider the necessity of looking more detailed into some of the critical and cultural dimensions of interactionism. Obviously, I was neither the first nor per- haps even the most qualified to do so. However, it took me by surprise how many interactionists in writing as well as in conversation used the notions of ‘critical’ or ‘cult...